Lisa Gerber

Advance your idea from concept to reality

  • About
  • Programs
    • Coaching
    • Creative collaboration
    • Storytelling Workshops
    • Storytelling for Nonprofits
  • Speaking
  • Book
  • Free
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • Video
    • Upcoming Events
  • Connect

Brand Loyalty – What Really Matters

October 12, 2010 by Lisa Gerber 7 Comments

Cup of Coffee

Cup of Coffee by naotakem

It all started with my morning coffee. I make Peet’s coffee at home because I love the taste. It has nothing to do with the packaging, and whether it’s noisy or not. It has nothing to do with the logo, and whether I like it or not.

It’s because it tastes good. Every morning.

As I sipped my coffee, I pondered my brand loyalty. As much as I love Peet’s, I put my loyalty to the test frequently. I occasionally buy a different brand of coffee. Maybe the store I’m in at the time doesn’t carry it. Maybe I’m trying something made locally. To be clear, I’m Not changing my buying habit because I think the name Peet’s is weird or goofy. As it turns out, I have yet to find anything I like more than Peet’s at home. So I keep returning to Peet’s, and they continue to earn my loyalty.

I watched with anticipation what Steve Jobs would do when everyone laughed Apple to death about the name of the iPad. Would Apple step back and rename it? No, they had a strategy. They know they have a solid product. Did people not buy it because of the name? Um, no. It is the fastest selling electronic device …ever. The name isn’t even a talking point anymore – because the product and the experience are so totally awesome, it has literally changed the way we see the word.

This morning, I read this about GAP’s new brand with dismay. Really? They’re pulling the new logo? because of social media backlash? Gap claims to have not had a clear understanding of the passion their loyal customers have for their brand. They moved forward with a strategy and story to evolve their brand identity and due to feedback, they are scrapping it. Steve Jobs was written up in New York Times for god’s sake, NEW YORK TIMES for the terrible name selection. Did they step down? No.

Personally, I like my brands with a bit of confidence. I don’t need you to ask my opinion every time you want to change something. Jon Hamm, in a recent interview on Fresh Air (NPR), told us what it was like to audition for the role of Don Draper. He had to exude confidence even though he wasn’t feeling it himself. We all have to manufacture confidence, because that sells. (Good advice for all us)

Of course, this confidence should be based on good customer knowledge. How are your customers making purchase decisions in your product segment? What matters to them most, truly? Find out if you don’t know. Create your product strategy and stick to it! Sure, packaging and logos matter in certain areas: For example, the bathroom soap on the counter should be in a cool package. But sometimes, just sometimes, I really do make my decision based on the (gasp) quality of the product, and not by what you said in your print ad, or what the logo on the shopping bag looks like.

Here’s what scares me with the new power the consumer has on social media channels: The people who care are speaking up. So it seems like a revolution. (Think Tea Party here. there I said it, I brought politics into it). Don’t forget about all the people out there who have so much more to do with their lives than complain about your logo on twitter. This is why I’m in LOVE with Jon Stewart’s Rally to Restore Sanity but I digress:

The people you are not hearing from complaining about a noisy package, a stupid name, a stupid logo. They are far too busy spending money buying your products and services because it serves their needs well.


Download From Transactional to Transformational: Elevate your organization’s positioning with effective storytelling.

[ssba]

Filed Under: Communications Tagged With: Apple, brand loyalty, Gap logo, iPad, Peet's coffee, Sun Chips

About Lisa Gerber

Lisa Gerber advises purpose-driven leaders on how to effectively use the power of storytelling and communication to influence action and bring ideas to life. She guides non-profits and individuals through the digital maze of constantly changing tools to build discovery, loyalty, and ultimately help them achieve their own big leaps. If you like what you read, contact us for more or to subscribe.

Comments

  1. Russell Heistuman says

    October 12, 2010 at 1:00 pm

    Good post. That said, and all brand issues aside, it was still a terrible logo.

    But you’re still right-on about projecting confidence in the decisions you make–the whole process of both the logo selection, the reasons why they chose the logo in the first place (the blue square equals heritage moving forward [gag]), the poorly-planned introduction, to their knee-jerk reaction to the criticism by crowdsourcing the design to the final punt back to the original logo reflects a tremendous lack of understanding their own brand as well as weakness in leadership. They claim that they misunderstood their customer’s passion for their brand (which I’m sure they did and still do) but to waffle and cave the way they did and see the solution as “everybody wants the old logo back” reflects the fact that they never understood their brand and what it should have taken to introduce an identity refresh to stimulate and move their already strong brand forward. It could have been done successfully.

    As a designer that specializes in identities, I just hope that other companies considering a brand or identity refresh aren’t scared off by this cautionary tale, but instead are emboldened to avoid GAP’s mistake and take the time and effort to plan a strategy and do it right and then stick to their decision confidently. Your customers will come along–specially if you truly are moving forward as a brand.

    Reply
    • Lisagerber says

      October 12, 2010 at 8:39 pm

      I have to agree, Russell. Not an exciting logo. You make a good point about hoping others aren’t scared off from it. Who knows where in the chain of command the situation went awry. Clients need to rely on their instincts, counsel from their experts and good customer understanding and hopefully we won’t bs blogging about them, here!!

      Reply
  2. Bob Reed says

    October 12, 2010 at 2:09 pm

    The Gap feel in to what could now be called the social media minders gap — when ephemeral public opinion wrongly dictates corporate action.

    BTW, I’m going to the Rally to Restore Sanity.

    Reply
    • Lisagerber says

      October 12, 2010 at 8:46 pm

      Bob, I was hoping someone would appreciate the political references and I sooooo want to go to the rally too.

      Reply
  3. Bob Reed says

    October 12, 2010 at 2:10 pm

    I meant “fell”. Yup. Long day.

    Reply
  4. Alan Lemire says

    October 12, 2010 at 7:42 pm

    A few thoughts…..
    Just how much time and money went into this redesign? Something like this usually gets outsourced to a rather large and expensive agency.
    How many senior execs signed off on this? Did anyone have the guts to say “NO”?
    In the end, Gap likes to think of themselves as visionary. Visionaries rarely rethink their decisions because of backlash. They just keep on being visionary, and leading.
    This would have been a great publicity stunt. Judging from the lack of “planning”, it wouldn’t surprise me to find out that this was the purpose all along.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Tweets that mention Brand Loyalty – What Really Matters | The 26-Hour Day -- Topsy.com says:
    October 12, 2010 at 11:39 am

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Lisa Gerber, Tierra Filhiol. Tierra Filhiol said: RT @lisagerber: Brand Loyalty – What Really Matters http://goo.gl/fb/yte9X (new post) […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay in Touch

Sign up for our newsletter / podcast to get emails of great stories like this.

Categories

  • A Walk in the Woods
  • Blog posts
  • Breaking Trail Podcast
  • Communications
  • Content
  • Entrepreneur
  • Social media
  • Strategy
  • Take a Big Leap

Search this site

Amazing Things My Clients Say

You are worth every penny we haven’t paid you yet.
Un-named Client A
You’ll notice I cc’d only you because I trust you not say something stupid.
Un-named Client B

What Others Are Saying

Thanks to Danny Brown for listing Lisa as a top 5 blogger to watch in 2013:

I first got to know Lisa Gerber from working with her when she was part of Arment Dietrich, and I knew then that she was a smart cookie… Her blog (has) become a staple part of my reading diet.

Copyright © 2015 Big Leap Creative · PO Box 1884, Sandpoint ID 83864 · 208.290.2525